When Houses Look Alike

An 11 year-old recently asked me, “how can you tell how old a house is?” It’s a good question, and I was thinking back on it for the rest of the day, wondering if I had answered it the best way. The truth is, it’s complex. Of course I am often checking my field guide, but my first two answers were materials and style.

Sometimes you walk through a neighborhood and it all but shouts its time period at you. That’s exactly what happened to me recently in Seattle’s neighborhood of Capitol Hill. I somehow wandered into a pocket of beautiful, ornate American Foursquare houses. One after another.

FullSizeRender copy 2FullSizeRender copy 3

The American Foursquare house, a Prairie style subtype characterized by a hipped roof, symmetry, and a front entry, originated in Chicago (Oak Park and River Forest in particular are home to landmark Prairie style houses). The Prairie Style is one of very few styles rooted in the United States. The style is credited to a group of Chicago architects, including Frank Lloyd Wright (who, no surprise, lived in Oak Park), that have since become known as the Prairie School. It was a short-lived but exceedingly popular style, and it quickly spread across the country through magazines and pattern books.

American Foursquare houses are common in the early 20th century suburbs of large cities (hello, Oak Park and Capitol Hill!), most being constructed between 1905 and 1915. The area of the Capitol Hill neighborhood that I had stumbled into rang true. I started looking up construction dates: 1907, 1910, 1906, 1906. We complain now about the look-alike houses, and maybe it has gone too far with the mirrored cookie-cutter houses of modern suburbia, but the truth is, that’s how style works. It tells of a time period, a place, and a trend.

FullSizeRender copy

One American Foursquare even as a matching little free library out front.

11 thoughts on “When Houses Look Alike

    1. Oo how interesting! I will have to look into this! Suspecting this is a local variation on the national style. Maybe that’s why these are so much more ornate? I saw some very similar ones in Portland this weekend, they had the same form and large brackets but not as intricate detailing/windows.

      Liked by 1 person

    2. Thanks for the article, so interesting! It does look like it was such a popular Seattle variation it became its own subtype: “Perhaps nowhere was this more evident than in the wide use of the foursquare style, which became so common that it was soon known as the Seattle Box. (Its popularity was not limited to the Northwest; in its many manifestations it was also known as the “Denver Box,” “Prairie Box,” and several other regional appellations.)”

      Liked by 1 person

  1. […] If you ask me, I’ll give you a whole symposium of lectures about why I dislike cookie-cutter vinyl-village-style houses. But Susie Trexler reminds us that at one time even the venerated American Foursquare was the trend, and they were built by the bazillions. Read When Houses Look Alike […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s